Why You Should Never Top Your Trees (And What to Do Instead)
Healthy trees are an investment in your home and your landscape. They provide shade, beauty, and long-term value — when they’re properly cared for. While there are many things you can do to support tree health, there’s one thing you should absolutely avoid: tree topping.
If you’re unsure about how to care for a tree, it’s always best to consult with a certified arborist or tree care specialist. But here’s why topping should never be part of your plan.
What Is Tree Topping?
Tree topping is the practice of cutting back large branches or the entire top of a mature tree. Some homeowners believe it’s a quick fix for reducing tree size or managing risk. In reality, it causes significant long-term harm.
Topped trees often appear disfigured and unnatural. More importantly, they’re weakened structurally, making them more vulnerable to pests, disease, and failure.
Why Topping Is Harmful
When you remove a large portion of the tree’s canopy, you create an imbalance between the roots and the remaining foliage. This impacts the tree’s ability to produce food through photosynthesis and leads to several issues:
-
Sun Scalding: The sudden loss of canopy exposes inner branches to harsh sunlight, causing sunburn and tissue damage.
-
Weak Regrowth: Topped trees respond by producing fast-growing shoots, or suckers, near the pruning cuts. These branches are often weakly attached and prone to breakage.
-
Disease and Decay: Large pruning cuts make it difficult for the tree to seal itself. The open wounds attract insects, fungi, and decay, compromising the tree’s natural defenses.
The Hidden Cost of Tree Topping
Topping doesn’t just harm your tree — it can hurt your wallet too.
-
Increased Maintenance: Topped trees quickly regrow to their original height, often with weaker, denser branches that require more frequent pruning.
-
Property Damage Risk: Weakened branches pose a safety hazard during storms.
-
Reduced Property Value: Healthy, well-maintained trees can increase your home’s value. Disfigured or failing trees do the opposite.
-
Replacement Costs: Severely topped trees may decline so much that removal and replacement become necessary.
What to Do Instead
The good news is that trees respond well to proper care. Here’s how to support long-term tree health:
-
Prune selectively, not excessively: Use professional techniques to shape and maintain trees safely.
-
Fertilize as needed: Fertilization can promote strong growth, especially in trees showing signs of decline or nutrient deficiency.
-
Water deeply and consistently: Especially during dry periods, consistent watering helps trees build resilience.
-
Protect your trees: Avoid damage from mowers or string trimmers, and watch for signs of pests or disease.
When in Doubt, Call a Tree Specialist
Every tree is different, and proper care depends on the species, location, and age of the tree. A certified arborist can evaluate your tree’s condition and recommend the best course of action — without resorting to topping.
Protect your trees now, and they’ll reward you with decades of shade, beauty, and value.
